The show where we take the news of the moment and put it in a longer story, so it actually makes sense.
Hosted by Sir Joshua The Historian
Sir Joshua The Historian explains why midterm elections almost always shake up Washington, how early and mail-in voting changed the game, and three things to watch before November 3.
Theme music: "Americana" (intro) and "Deliberate Thought" (outro) by Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com), licensed under Creative Commons Attribution 3.0.
Welcome to Joshua Unfiltered. I'm Sir Joshua The Historian your host and guide. This is the show where we take the news of the moment and put it in a longer story, so it actually makes sense.
Today we are starting with a simple question, and it is one that will matter a lot over the next two weeks. Why do midterm elections almost always shake up Washington, even when nothing seems to have changed?
Here is where we are right now. The midterm elections are on Tuesday, November third, 2026. That is fifteen days away. And voting is not waiting for that day. Millions of Americans have already cast early ballots. Campaigns are moving money around, pulling back from some House races and pushing into others. Both parties are reading the same polls and coming to the same conclusion. This is going to be close, and it is going to matter.
If you have followed American politics for a while, that sentence will sound familiar. It sounds familiar because it is almost always true in a midterm year. And that is our first point today. Midterms are not a strange accident. They are a pattern. And history can help us understand why that pattern keeps repeating.
Let us start with the basics. In the United States, the president serves a four year term. Members of the House of Representatives serve two year terms, so every House seat is on the ballot in a midterm year. Senators serve six year terms, so about one third of the Senate is on the ballot. This year, thirty-five Senate seats are up for election. Add in governors, state legislatures, and local offices, and a midterm is not a small election. It is a national check in, held halfway through a presidency.
And here is the pattern that political scientists keep finding. Since the end of World War II, the party that holds the White House has lost House seats in almost every midterm. The average loss is about twenty-seven House seats. That is not a small shift. That is enough to flip control of the House in a lot of years.
Think about how big some of those losses have been. In 1994, Democrats lost fifty-four House seats during President Clinton's first term, and Republicans took control of the House for the first time in four decades. In 2010, Democrats lost sixty-three House seats during President Obama's first term. In 2018, during President Trump's first term, Democrats gained forty-one House seats and took back the House. And then in 2022, Democrats lost only nine seats, which by historical standards was a very good result for a president's party.
So why does this keep happening? There are three explanations that historians and political scientists come back to again and again, and they are worth holding in your head as you watch this year unfold.
The first is that midterms work like a referendum. In a presidential year, voters are choosing a future. In a midterm year, voters are grading a record. If prices are high, if people are worried about jobs, if a war overseas feels endless, or if people simply feel tired of the tone in Washington, the midterm becomes a place to say so. The president is not on the ballot, but the president's party is.
The second explanation is about turnout. In a presidential election, turnout is high and broad. In a midterm, turnout is usually lower, and the people who do show up tend to be more motivated. Often, that means the party out of power is more energized. Anger is a strong motivator. Contentment is not. So the opposition often has an enthusiasm advantage, even if the country as a whole is more evenly divided.
The third explanation is sometimes called the thermostat effect. Think of public opinion like the temperature in a room. If a president pushes policy hard in one direction, some voters will want to cool things down. They are not necessarily rejecting everything. They are adjusting. They are sending a signal that they want balance, or a slower pace, or a different set of priorities.
Now, there are exceptions, and the exceptions are revealing. In 1934, during the Great Depression, President Roosevelt's party actually gained seats, because many voters supported the New Deal programs. In 1998, President Clinton's party gained seats, in part because many voters reacted against the impeachment effort and the economy was strong. In 2002, after the attacks of September eleventh, President Bush's party gained seats, in a moment of national unity and very high presidential approval.
Notice what those exceptions have in common. Each one involved an unusual national moment. A deep crisis, a backlash against overreach, or a rally around the flag. When those conditions are not present, the normal pattern tends to return.
That brings us to our second big point today, and it is one that changes how midterms feel. Voting itself has changed. We no longer live in a country where almost everyone votes on one single Tuesday.
For much of American history, Election Day was a communal event. People went to their local polling place, on one day, and cast a ballot. Early voting existed in narrow forms, especially for soldiers. During the Civil War, soldiers voted absentee by mailing ballots home. Over time, states extended absentee voting to civilians who had a specific reason, like travel or illness.
The modern change came slowly, then quickly. California removed the excuse requirement for mail voting in the late 1970s. Texas offered in person early voting in the 1980s. More states followed in the 1990s, and after the disputed presidential election in 2000, many more states added early in person voting to make election administration smoother.
Look at how far that shift has gone. In the 2000 general election, about forty percent of voting age citizens lived in states with at least one early voting option, and about fourteen percent of ballots were cast before Election Day. By 2016, that share had risen to about forty percent. In 2020, during the pandemic, it jumped to about sixty-nine percent. In 2022, it settled back to about fifty percent. Today, nearly ninety-seven percent of voting age citizens live in states offering at least one option to vote before Election Day.
That matters for campaigns, and it matters for you as a voter. Campaigns can no longer save everything for the final weekend. They have to reach voters over weeks, not days. Advertising, door knocking, and messaging have to work across a longer window. And voters have to make decisions earlier, sometimes before late breaking news arrives.
It also matters for how we talk about results. On election night, we may see early votes counted first in some states, and Election Day votes counted first in others. That does not mean something is wrong. It means different states count in different orders. Patience on election night is not just a virtue. It is part of understanding the system.
Now let us bring this back to the present, and to what you should watch over the next two weeks. I want to give you three things to watch, not thirty.
First, watch the House. The House is where the midterm pattern usually hits hardest, because every seat is up. With a narrow majority to start, even an average size loss would be enough to flip control. Watch not just who wins, but by how much. A narrow flip and a broad wave send different signals about 2028.
Second, watch the Senate map. The Senate is more insulated, because only about one third of seats are up, and many of those seats are in states that lean strongly one way. To take control, Democrats would need to hold competitive seats and win several seats currently held by Republicans. Watch states like North Carolina, Maine, and Ohio, and watch whether races in traditionally Republican leaning states become unexpectedly competitive. That is often a sign of a broader national mood.
Third, watch the economy as people actually live it. In my work in hospitality, I see this every day. People do not experience the economy as a chart. They experience it as menu prices, grocery bills, gas prices, rent, and whether they can afford to go out with family on a Friday night. When voters say they are worried about the economy, they are often talking about that daily experience. That is why costs for fuel, food, housing, and health care keep showing up in polls, and why they keep shaping midterm votes.
And here is where history and religion and politics meet, in a way I want to explore more in future episodes. American voters have always brought their deepest beliefs into the voting booth. Faith, community, ideas about duty and service, ideas about freedom and responsibility. Those beliefs do not determine a single election, but they shape how people hear a message, and how they decide who to trust.
So here is my takeaway for today. Midterms are not noise. They are the moment when the country pauses, grades the presidency, and recalibrates. The pattern is real. The president's party usually loses ground. Turnout and mood matter more than any single poll. And because voting now stretches over weeks, not just one day, the election is already underway.
If you take one question into the next two weeks, let it be this one. Not who is up by two points today, but what is the country trying to correct? Is it asking for a change in direction, a change in tone, or just a check on power? History suggests that is the question midterms actually answer.
Thank you for listening. If you enjoyed what you heard. If you learned something new. Or, if you received some form of value, please share this show with someone you know. I will see you next time.