Joshua Unfiltered podcast cover art

Joshua Unfiltered

The show where we take the news of the moment and put it in a longer story, so it actually makes sense.

Hosted by Sir Joshua The Historian


Episode 003: The Texas Senate Race and the 17th Amendment

October 19, 2026 · 9 minutes

Fifteen days before Election Day, Sir Joshua The Historian profiles both candidates in the Texas Senate race — Ken Paxton and James Talarico — controversies included, no punches pulled on either side. Then the longer story: the 17th Amendment, which took the choice of senators from state legislatures and gave it directly to voters in 1913 — and why your host disagrees with it.

Theme music: "Americana" (intro) and "Deliberate Thought" (outro) by Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com), licensed under Creative Commons Attribution 3.0.


Full transcript

Welcome to Joshua Unfiltered. I'm Sir Joshua The Historian your host and guide. This is the show where we take the news of the moment and put it in a longer story, so it actually makes sense.

Fifteen days from now, Texans will elect a United States Senator. Early voting is open right now, as we speak. And the choice on the ballot comes down to two of the most controversial figures in Texas politics: Republican Ken Paxton and Democrat James Talarico. The polls call it a toss-up. The money makes it historic. Today I want to do two things. First, give you a straight profile of both men, controversies included, no punches pulled on either side. And second, tell you the story of the constitutional amendment that put this choice directly in your hands. An amendment, I should warn you, that I happen to disagree with.

Start with the stakes, because this is not just a Texas story. The Senate right now sits at fifty-three Republicans to forty-seven Democrats. Democrats need a net gain of four seats to take control. Thirty-five seats are on the ballot this November, and the forecasters list Texas among the handful of races most likely to decide who runs the chamber. A Democratic pickup here goes most of the way toward flipping the Senate. A Republican hold likely preserves it. That is why the money flooding into this state looks the way it does.

And the money is staggering. Talarico's campaign reported raising sixty-four million dollars in a single quarter, the third quarter of this year, a record for any Senate campaign in any quarter, ever. The vast majority of it in small donations. Outside groups have spent hundreds of millions more on both sides. By every measure, this is on pace to be the most expensive Senate race in Texas history.

Now, how did we get this matchup? On the Republican side, Ken Paxton did not just win a primary. He took out a four-term incumbent United States Senator. John Cornyn had held that seat for more than two decades. Paxton challenged him, forced a runoff in May, and won it by nearly two to one. It was the first time a challenger had defeated an incumbent senator in a Texas primary since 1970. On the Democratic side, James Talarico won his March primary outright with fifty-two and a half percent of the vote, no runoff needed. So here we are. Two nominees, no incumbent, fifteen days out.

The polling, for what it is worth. Nearly every public poll taken in October shows Talarico narrowly ahead, most of them within the margin of error. But a word of caution from your historian. Texas has a documented habit of under-polling Republicans. In 2018, Ted Cruz beat his final polling average by about four points. In 2024, he did it again, winning by eight and a half when the polls said four. So treat every poll you see the way you would treat a weather forecast two weeks out. Interesting. Not destiny.

All right. The profiles. Ken Paxton is sixty-three years old, born in North Dakota, and has been the Attorney General of Texas since 2015. Before that, a decade in the Texas House and a term in the Texas Senate. As attorney general, he became a national figure. He filed the lawsuit Texas v. Pennsylvania after the 2020 election. He spoke at the rally on January sixth, 2021. And by one count, he sued the Biden administration one hundred and six times.

Now the controversies, because I promised no punches pulled. In 2015, months after taking office as attorney general, Paxton was indicted in Collin County on felony securities fraud charges, accused of steering investors toward a tech company without disclosing he would earn a commission. That case hung over him for nearly a decade. In 2024 it was resolved through a pretrial diversion agreement. He paid nearly three hundred thousand dollars in restitution, completed community service and ethics training, and the charges were dismissed, with no admission of guilt and no conviction. Then, in May of 2023, the Republican-led Texas House impeached him on twenty articles, including bribery and abuse of office, centered on allegations that he misused his office to benefit a political donor. The vote was one hundred twenty-one to twenty-three. After a two-week trial that September, the Texas Senate acquitted him on every article. He has never been convicted of anything.

James Talarico is thirty-seven, an eighth-generation Texan, born in Round Rock. Before politics, he taught sixth-grade language arts at a middle school in San Antonio, in one of the poorest zip codes in Texas. He has a master's in education policy from Harvard and a Master of Divinity from Austin Presbyterian Theological Seminary. He was elected to the Texas House in 2018 at the age of twenty-nine, flipping a district Donald Trump had carried. His legislative record includes a Texas school finance overhaul, a twenty-five dollar monthly cap on insulin copays, and funding for child care and pre-kindergarten. He says he is the only member of the Texas Legislature who has never taken corporate PAC money.

His controversies. First, his record on gender policy. As a state representative, Talarico voted against bills restricting transgender athletes and barring certain medical procedures for minors, at one point calling the issue a manufactured controversy. As a Senate candidate this year, he has taken more moderate positions, saying he opposes gender reassignment surgeries for minors and would support a national ban. Republicans call that a flip-flop. Transgender rights advocates have criticized the shift from the other direction. Talarico's response is that the original bill was overly broad and that he tried to narrow it through amendments. And one note of fairness. Attack ads claiming he supported taxpayer-funded procedures for children were rated false by PolitiFact. He cast no such vote. Second, just this month, the New York Times reported on a network of TikTok accounts paid by the view to post positive content about Talarico, organized through a firm with no federal election filings, so the funding source is unknown. Talarico's campaign says it had no role in it and denies wrongdoing. That story is unresolved.

So there they are. Two controversial candidates, and fifteen days for Texas to choose between them. And that choice, the fact that it sits with you at all, is the longer story I promised.

For the first one hundred and twenty-four years of the republic, you did not vote for your United States Senator. Under the original Constitution, senators were chosen by state legislatures. The idea was that the Senate would represent the states as states, a kind of embassy of state governments inside the federal government, insulated from the passions of the popular vote. That was the design. And for a long time, it worked badly. Seats were bought. Bribery of state legislators by wealthy interests was so routine that critics called the Senate the Millionaires' Club. Partisan deadlocks in legislatures left seats empty for months, sometimes years. Delaware once took two hundred and seventeen ballots over one hundred and fourteen days and still ended up with a two-year vacancy.

The reform came from the Populist and Progressive movements, and it came fast. Congress passed the Seventeenth Amendment in the spring of 1912. Texas ratified it on February seventh, 1913, the sixteenth state to do so. By May of that year it was the law of the land: senators, quote, elected by the people thereof, for six years. One hundred and thirteen years later, every vote cast in this Senate race is an exercise of that power.

Now here is where I get unfiltered. I disagree with the Seventeenth Amendment. I think the original design was better, and I will tell you why. The founders built the Senate to represent the states themselves, not just a second batch of popular constituencies. State legislatures choosing senators gave state governments a direct voice in federal power. It was a structural defense of federalism. Direct election turned the Senate into a smaller, slower House of Representatives, and it turned Senate races into what you see right in front of you: a four-hundred-million-dollar media spectacle where two candidates must win over millions of individual voters instead of answering to a few hundred legislators. I am not saying the old system was clean. It certainly was not. I am saying the new system traded one set of corruptions for another, and I prefer the original intention.

And I am not alone in thinking the question is still open. In June of this year, a congressman from Texas filed a House resolution calling for the repeal of the Seventeenth Amendment and a return to legislative selection of senators. Eight co-sponsors signed on. Whatever you think of that idea, it tells you the amendment itself is still contested ground, more than a century after ratification.

So here is where it lands. Fifteen days from now, you will walk into a voting booth, or you already have during early voting, and you will make a choice the founders never intended you to make, under an amendment I wish had never passed. That is the system we have. Know its history, know both candidates, controversies and all, and then go exercise the power the Seventeenth Amendment gave you, whether I like it or not.

Thank you for listening. If you enjoyed what you heard. If you learned something new. Or, if you received some form of value, please share this show with someone you know. I will see you next time.

← Back to the latest episodes ← The Archives