The show where we take the news of the moment and put it in a longer story, so it actually makes sense.
Hosted by Sir Joshua The Historian
Two days after Election Day, Sir Joshua The Historian answers Episodes 1 and 3: the midterm pattern held and ran through the Senate, Texas swept all eight statewide races for the Democrats while Paxton carried 214 counties to Talarico's 40, and the map itself became the argument about the 17th Amendment. From the county map to the Brazos County split ticket, from the redistricting backfire to the races still open — this is the sequel episode.
Figures as of the night of November 4, 2026. All results unofficial until the Texas canvass, November 21 to December 7, 2026.
Theme music: "Americana" (intro) and "Deliberate Thought" (outro) by Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com), licensed under Creative Commons Attribution.
Welcome to Joshua Unfiltered. I'm Sir Joshua The Historian your host and guide. This is the show where we take the news of the moment and put it in a longer story, so it actually makes sense.
Tuesday night was historic, and I do not use that word lightly. Democrats swept every statewide office on the Texas ballot, took control of both chambers of Congress, and won statewide in Texas for the first time since 1994. This episode is a sequel. In Episode 1, I asked what the country was trying to correct. In Episode 3, I profiled the Senate seat most likely to decide who runs the chamber. Tuesday night answered both questions, and the answers are worth sitting with.
Start with Episode 1. The pattern I laid out there has held since the Second World War: the president's party loses House seats in almost every midterm, by an average of about twenty-seven. In 1994, Democrats lost fifty-four. In 2010, they lost sixty-three. In 2018, they gained forty-one and retook the House. In 2022, the loss was only nine. The exceptions prove the rule, and there are only three of them: 1934, when the country was rallying behind the New Deal; 1998, when an impeachment backlash met a strong economy; and 2002, in the unity after September 11th. Each one had an unusual national moment behind it. 2026 was not an exception year. It was the pattern, and then some — because this time it did not stop at the House. It ran through the Senate too, with only a third of the seats on the ballot.
Episode 1 named the states to watch: North Carolina, Maine, and Ohio, plus traditionally Republican-leaning states becoming unexpectedly competitive. All three named states flipped. So did Kansas, South Carolina, and Texas. Democrats flipped seven Republican-held Senate seats and lost none, taking the chamber fifty-four to forty-four. In North Carolina, Roy Cooper beat Michael Whatley by nearly twenty points. In Maine, Troy Jackson beat Susan Collins, ending a tenure of about thirty years. In Kansas, Adam Hamilton won the first Democratic Senate seat from that state since 1932. In Ohio, Sherrod Brown came back. In South Carolina, Annie Andrews won the first Democratic Senate seat there since Strom Thurmond switched parties in the 1960s. In Iowa, Josh Turek won an open seat. And in Texas, the margin was twelve points.
Episode 1 also offered three explanations for a midterm, and asked which one fit: a referendum on the record, an enthusiasm gap, or what political scientists call the thermostat effect — the country turning the temperature back down after a stretch of one party's rule. And it closed with a question I want to put to you again tonight: what is the country trying to correct? Is it asking for a change in direction, a change in tone, or just a check on power? Tuesday's answer looks like all three at once. The country wanted a check, and it took one — in the Senate, in the House, and across the state of Texas.
Now Texas, because Texas is where this story gets strange. Democrats won all eight statewide races. James Talarico beat Ken Paxton for the United States Senate, fifty-five point one percent to forty-three, a margin of about one point two million votes. Gina Hinojosa beat Greg Abbott for governor, fifty-two point eight to forty-five point seven — the first Latina governor of Texas, and the first Democrat in the office since Ann Richards was elected in 1990. Vikki Goodwin beat Dan Patrick for lieutenant governor, the first woman to hold the office and the first Democrat in twenty-seven years. Nathan Johnson beat Mayes Middleton for attorney general, the first Democrat there since 1994. Sarah Eckhardt won for comptroller. Benjamin Flores won for land commissioner. Clayton Tucker won for agriculture commissioner, the first Democrat there since Jim Hightower left in 1991. Jon Rosenthal won for railroad commissioner. Democrats also led in seven statewide judicial races. That is a sweep, and it had not happened in thirty-two years.
But look at the other half of Austin, because divided government is the rest of the story. The Texas Senate stayed Republican, nineteen to twelve. In my own district, Charles Schwertner held his seat, but far more narrowly than before — about fifty-three percent to forty-seven, against seventy-one point six percent in 2022. And the Texas House went Democratic, the first Democratic majority since Republicans took the chamber in 2003, with twenty-two seats flipped. So Texas now has a Democratic governor, a Republican Senate, and a Democratic House. If you want to know what divided government looks like, you are about to watch it.
Here is where the map becomes the argument. Paxton carried two hundred fourteen of Texas's two hundred fifty-four counties. Talarico carried forty. And Talarico won the state by twelve points. Sit with that for a moment, because it is the whole episode in one picture: a mostly red map with a blue winner. And it was not only the Senate race. In the governor's race, the Republican carried two hundred seventeen counties to the Democrat's thirty-seven. Lieutenant governor: two hundred eighteen to thirty-six. Attorney general: two hundred eighteen to thirty-six. Comptroller: two hundred twenty to thirty-four. Land commissioner: two hundred nineteen to thirty-five. Agriculture: two hundred nineteen to thirty-five. Railroad commissioner: two hundred eighteen to thirty-six. Republicans carried the map in every statewide race. Democrats carried the people in every statewide race. Eight races, the same picture eight times.
Bring it home to Brazos County, because that is where I live and where this pattern gets personal. Brazos went Democratic at the top of the ticket — Talarico over Paxton, forty-one thousand four hundred twenty-five to thirty-six thousand six hundred fifty-five, and Hinojosa over Abbott, thirty-nine thousand four hundred seventy-five to thirty-eight thousand eight hundred eighty-three — and Republican in the other six statewide races. One county, a split ticket, both directions at once. And in the Tenth Congressional District, which covers much of this county, Chris Gober beat Caitlin Rourk fifty-three point eight to forty-six point two statewide in the district, but inside Brazos County alone it was nearly a tie: forty thousand one hundred five to thirty-nine thousand two hundred eighteen. Episode 1 talked about the economy as it is lived, not as it is charted: menu prices, groceries, gas, rent, a Friday night out. I will not tell you that is what decided Tuesday night. I will ask whether it did, because that is the question a restaurant town asks honestly.
There is a second map story in Texas, and it is the one about the mapmakers. In 2025, the legislature drew a new congressional map at the urging of the president, meant to flip five Democratic-held seats. It largely failed. Democrats held Henry Cuellar's seat and Vicente Gonzalez's seat — Gonzalez's district had been drawn ten points toward Trump, and he won it by double digits — and they won the redrawn Thirty-Fifth District with Johnny Garcia. Then they flipped two Republican-held seats: the Fifteenth, where Bobby Pulido beat incumbent Monica De La Cruz, and the open Twenty-Third, where Katy Padilla Stout beat Brandon Herrera. All thirty-eight Texas seats in Congress are now called, twenty-four Republican and fourteen Democratic, and Republicans finished with fewer Texas seats than the twenty-five they held before the new map. The map that was drawn to gain seats lost them.
Now Episode 3, answered. Episode 3 opened with the Senate at fifty-three to forty-seven and Democrats needing a net gain of four, with Texas among the handful of races most likely to decide who runs the chamber. The net gain was seven. I said in Episode 3 that a Democratic pickup in Texas goes most of the way toward flipping the Senate. It did. Episode 3 called the race a toss-up, with Talarico narrowly ahead in the October polls. The result was fifty-five to forty-three — not a toss-up at all. And Episode 3's polling caution cut the other way this time. I warned that Texas has a habit of under-polling Republicans: Ted Cruz beat his final polling average by about four points in 2018, and by eight and a half against a four-point polling lead in 2024. In 2026, the polls under-called the Democrat.
The money arc finished the way Episode 3 said it might. Talarico's sixty-four-million-dollar third quarter was a record for any Senate campaign in any quarter, and the race finished as the most expensive Senate race in American history. And the primary chain: Paxton took out four-term incumbent John Cornyn in a runoff by nearly two to one, the first challenger to beat an incumbent Texas senator in a primary since 1970 — and that seat is now held by a Democrat. I said in Episode 3 that I thought neither man was a good choice, and I profiled both with their controversies included. The voters chose anyway. That is how this works, whether I like the choice or not.
Which brings us back to the argument underneath Episode 3, the one I have never hidden. Direct election, I said, turned Senate races into a four-hundred-million-dollar media spectacle, and traded one set of corruptions for another, and I prefer the original intention. The history, briefly, because it matters: for a hundred and twenty-four years, state legislatures chose senators. The chamber became known as the Millionaires' Club. Delaware once took two hundred seventeen ballots over a hundred and fourteen days and still left the seat vacant for two years. Congress passed the Seventeenth Amendment in the spring of 1912. Texas ratified it on February seventh, 1913, the sixteenth state. And the point of Tuesday night is the point of the amendment itself: under direct election, the statewide total decides, no matter how the counties fall. Two hundred fourteen counties do not outweigh forty when the forty hold the people. That is my objection, stated openly, as it was in Episode 3. And there is an open question to carry forward: in June of 2026, a resolution to repeal the amendment was introduced in the House with eight co-sponsors. We will see where that goes.
Episode 1 taught one more lesson, and it is the one that keeps this episode honest: patience on election night is not just a virtue. It is part of understanding the system, because states count in different orders and on different schedules. So here is what is still open, stated plainly. In my own backyard, the Fourteenth District race for the Texas House is too close to call: Janet Dudding leads Paul Dyson by three hundred fifteen votes, thirty thousand seven hundred eighty to thirty thousand four hundred sixty-five. In Alaska, Mary Peltola leads Dan Sullivan by six hundred thirty-seven votes with about three-quarters of the vote counted, and ranked-choice tabulation comes November eighteenth if nobody clears fifty percent. In Mississippi, the margin itself is disputed between tallies, affidavit ballots are still outstanding, and a December first runoff is possible if nobody reaches fifty percent. The final national House tally is still incomplete. The Bryan school district's tax rate election and the Brazos County Precinct Four constable race have no located results yet. And none of any of this is final until the Texas canvass, November twenty-first to December seventh. These are not footnotes. They are the system counting in its own order, and a longer story waits for them.
So what was the country trying to correct? A change in direction, a change in tone, or just a check on power? After Tuesday, I think the honest answer is that it wanted a check, and it used every lever it had: the Senate, the House, the governor's mansion, and all eight statewide offices in Texas. And the longer story is this: the first statewide Democratic wins in Texas since 1994 did not come from a state that changed its shape. They came from a state whose map stayed mostly red while its people voted blue. Feeling blue, or seeing red? Tuesday night, Texas was both at once — and that is why the map, more than any single race, is the story of this election.
Thank you for listening. If you enjoyed what you heard. If you learned something new. Or, if you received some form of value, please share this show with someone you know. I'll see you next time.
Texas Senate county map (interactive) — who carried each of Texas’s 254 counties, and by how much.
Texas 2026 county-by-county results (CSV) — Republican and Democratic votes in all eight statewide races, for all 254 counties.