The show where we take the news of the moment and put it in a longer story, so it actually makes sense.
Hosted by Sir Joshua The Historian
Protestantism isn't a denomination — it's a family of churches born from one protest, defined by five 'alones,' and made American by a revival. Sir Joshua The Historian opens the Denominations Series with the word itself: a legal protest at Speyer in 1529, five solas, and the First Great Awakening.
Theme music: "Americana" (intro) and "Deliberate Thought" (outro) by Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com), licensed under Creative Commons Attribution.
Welcome to Joshua Unfiltered. I am Sir Joshua The Historian your host and guide. This is not the news of the moment. This is a lesson in history and religion, and we are going to walk through it slowly, so it actually makes sense.
What is a Protestant? It sounds like a simple question, and it is not. There are nearly a billion Protestants in the world, and they do not agree with each other on baptism, or the Lord's Supper, or who runs the church, or even how a person is saved. So what holds them together? The answer starts with a word that was political before it was theological.
In 1529, in Speyer, a city on the Rhine in Germany, six princes and fourteen cities protested an order to enforce the old religion, the Roman Catholic faith: the pope, the Mass, and the seven sacraments. Three years earlier, at the same city, the Diet had agreed, in its recess of 1526, that until a church council could settle the question, every ruler should live and govern as he could answer for it before God and the emperor. The evangelical princes took that as their right to reform their territories. By the time of the second Diet, the papacy had changed hands twice: Leo X was dead, Adrian VI had reigned a single year, and Clement VII now held the office. Now the emperor's party wanted that agreement taken back, and the Edict of Worms enforced instead. The Lutheran princes said no, and on April 25 they said it in writing, as a formal protest. They gave two reasons. First, a decision made unanimously in 1526 could not be undone by a majority vote three years later. And second, in matters of God's honor and the salvation of souls, every man must stand and give account before God for himself, and no majority can bind his conscience against the Word of God. Their protest gave the movement its name. Protestant. It was a legal protest first, and a church second. Their motto was simple: the Word of God abideth forever.
Twelve years earlier, in 1517, a German monk named Martin Luther wrote ninety-five points for debate about indulgences and mailed them to his archbishop. The pope at the time was Leo X, who had authorized the sale of indulgences to pay for the rebuilding of Saint Peter's Basilica in Rome. An indulgence was a paper the church sold that claimed to shorten a soul's time in purgatory. The salesmen had a jingle for it: as soon as the coin in the coffer rings, the soul from purgatory springs. Luther's first point answered it directly: the whole life of believers should be repentance, not a purchase. His sixty-second point said the true treasure of the church is the gospel, not a treasury of merit. And his eighty-sixth asked the question nobody in Rome wanted asked: if the pope can release souls from purgatory, why does he not do it out of love, instead of selling the release?
You have probably heard that Luther nailed those ninety-five points to a church door. That part is a story told decades later by a friend of his. What Luther did was send a letter. The letter was printed, and the printing press did the rest. Within weeks the theses were all over Germany, in Latin first and then in German, and a local argument about indulgences had become a movement.
The protest had a spine, and it was five short phrases in Latin, each one ending in the word alone. Scripture alone. Faith alone. Grace alone. Christ alone. To God alone be the glory.
Scripture alone meant the Bible, not the pope and not church tradition, is the final authority. That was the break. Rome said the church stands over the Bible, that tradition and the pope's teaching carry the same weight as Scripture. The Reformers said the opposite: the Bible judges the church, not the other way around. Everything else followed from it.
Faith alone meant a person is made right with God by trusting Christ, not by doing enough good works or buying enough indulgences to tip the scale. The church of that day taught that grace was a substance the church handed out, through the sacraments, in measured doses. The Reformers said grace is not a substance and it is not measured. It is God's favor, given freely, received by faith.
Grace alone is the same truth from the other side. If salvation is by faith, it is because God gives what man cannot earn. No one contributes to it. No one cooperates with it in the sense of paying part of the price. The gift is whole, or it is not a gift.
Christ alone meant there is one mediator between God and man, not a chain of priests and saints standing in between. The saints could be honored as examples, the Reformers said, but they are not intercessors, and Mary is not a co-mediator. One man, Jesus Christ, stands between God and sinners, and he is enough.
And to God alone be the glory meant the whole of it, the whole story, ends with God, not with man. Not with the pope's glory, not with the church's glory, not with the preacher's glory. Every good thing in salvation comes from God, and so every bit of the praise goes back to God.
So what actually changed? Four things. Authority moved from the pope and tradition to Scripture. Salvation moved from the church's treasury of merit to faith in Christ. The sacraments went from seven to two. The old church counted seven: baptism, confirmation, the Eucharist, penance, anointing of the sick, holy orders, and matrimony. Luther kept two, baptism and the Lord's Supper, because those are the two Christ himself commanded, and the two the Scriptures record him instituting. Baptism comes from his last words in the Gospel of Matthew, chapter 28, verse 19: go and make disciples of all nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit. And the Supper comes from the night he was betrayed, in the same Gospel, chapter 26, verse 26: take and eat, this is my body. And verse 28: this is my blood of the covenant, which is poured out for many for the forgiveness of sins. Both are quoted here in the New International Version. And the priesthood opened up: every believer a priest, no special class standing between a Christian and God. As the apostle Peter put it, in his first letter, chapter 2, verse 9: you are a chosen people, a royal priesthood, a holy nation.
That last one is why Protestant worship looks the way it does. No pope, no purgatory, no indulgences, no saints called on as intercessors. The Mass became a sermon and a table. The confessional became a prayer. The church answered back, of course. The Council of Trent, meeting on and off from 1545 to 1563, declared that tradition stands beside Scripture, that justification comes by faith plus works, and that anyone who taught otherwise was outside the church. The lines were drawn, and they have stayed drawn for nearly five hundred years.
The Orthodox churches never joined this protest. They kept their bishops, their icons, their seven sacraments. The Catholics kept theirs too. So the Christian world after the Reformation had three great branches, not two, and the Protestant branch was the one that kept splitting.
But a protest is not a church, and for two hundred years the Protestant churches in America were mostly the churches the colonists brought with them. Then something happened that made them American. It was the First Great Awakening.
By the 1730s, the old parish system was failing. The churches were there, but the faith had gone flat. People assented to the doctrines and lived like everyone else. The Puritan idea of the new birth had faded into respectability. Then the preaching changed.
It started with communion seasons among the Scotch-Irish, whole communities gathering for days at a time, and with preachers like Gilbert Tennent and Jonathan Edwards. Edwards preached at Northampton in 1734, and his town was shaken. Then George Whitefield came, the Grand Itinerant, and in seventy-three days in New England he preached a hundred and thirty sermons and rode eight hundred miles. Benjamin Franklin went to hear him and estimated that twenty-five thousand people could hear his voice at once.
Not everyone approved. Charles Chauncy of Boston wrote a whole book against the revival, warning that it was enthusiasm and disorder. Harvard and Yale condemned it. James Davenport, one of the preachers, went too far even for the revivalists, judging other ministers unsaved and burning their books in public. The Awakening had its excesses, and its enemies made sure everyone knew it.
But the Awakening did three things, and they are the reason American Protestantism looks the way it does. First, it undercut the authority of the ministers. If a farmer could be born again in a field, he did not need a learned man to tell him what God said. Second, it made a new kind of Christianity, Evangelicalism, a faith of the heart and the decision, not just the creed. And third, it gave the colonies their first shared religious identity, and with it the idea of denominations, different churches that were still one Christianity.
The Baptists were the great beneficiaries. Ninety-eight Separate Congregational churches, formed in the heat of the revival, most of them became Baptist. And the revival built colleges to train the new kind of minister: Princeton in 1746, Brown in 1764, Rutgers in 1766, Dartmouth in 1769.
That is the rigid foundation. The First Great Awakening is what made Protestantism American. The Second would make it democratic, and the Third would split it open, but the First is where the colonies first felt themselves to be one people, and it was a religious feeling before it was a political one.
So what is a Protestant? Not a denomination. A family. A family of churches born from one protest, defined by five alones, and made American by a revival. One protest became fourteen traditions: Lutheran, Anabaptist, Anglican, Presbyterian, Baptist, Methodist, Unitarian, the African Methodist Episcopal, the Latter-day Saints, the Restoration Movement, the Adventists, the National Baptists, the Pentecostals, and the Non-denominational churches. The next four episodes will walk through them, one family at a time. And if any of the words in this series are new to you, the glossary on the website defines every one of them in plain language, because you have the right to know what these words mean.
Next time, the Reformation families: the Lutherans, the Anglicans, the Presbyterians, and the Anabaptists. Four answers to Rome, and each one still defines the church that gave it.
Now here is where I get Unfiltered.
As a Catholic, I believe in the seven sacraments, the intercession of Saints, & the authority of the Church. Things the Protestants either disagree with or hate outright as a foundational element to their faith. And I am at peace with that. Because I can set my beliefs aside and do the work to better understand their faith and their story. Catholics and Protestants are still under attack because of their faith to this day. The sooner we can acknowledge this and set our differences aside, the sooner we will stand as a united front against the dark forces that wish to destroy us. The Protestant faith began as a protest, a legitimate one, against the papacy over practices that I consider to be wrong. The church eventually rescinded those practices completing the work of a humble monk from Germany.
Thank you for listening to Joshua Unfiltered. And this is a value-for-value show. That means if you enjoyed what you heard, if you learned something new, if you received some form of value from listening, I kindly ask that you please share this show with someone you know. In the morning, and thank you for your courage.
History
Scripture (New International Version)
Source list revised November 12, 2026 — citations now point to the underlying works directly.