The show where we take the news of the moment and put it in a longer story, so it actually makes sense.
Hosted by Sir Joshua The Historian
One protest became four families. Sir Joshua The Historian meets the Lutherans, the Anglicans, the Presbyterians, and the Anabaptists — four answers to Rome, from Luther's faith alone and the Augsburg Confession to Richard Hooker giving the Elizabethan settlement its mind, Calvin's sovereignty of God, and the free church of believers only. Within a generation, the Peace of Augsburg wrote the first answer into law; a century later, Westphalia wrote three.
Theme music: "Americana" (intro) and "Deliberate Thought" (outro) by Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com), licensed under Creative Commons Attribution.
Welcome to Joshua Unfiltered. I'm Sir Joshua The Historian your host and guide. This is not the news of the moment. This is a lesson in history and religion, and we are going to walk through it slowly, so it actually makes sense.
Last time, we asked a simple question. What is a Protestant? And the answer turned out to be a family, not a denomination. A family of churches born from one protest, defined by five alones, and made American by a revival. But a family has branches, and the branches do not agree with each other. In this episode, we meet the four families of the Reformation. Each one answered Rome differently. Each one still defines the church that gave it.
It all starts with one monk, one argument, and one letter. In fifteen seventeen, Martin Luther was a German monk and a teacher of theology at Wittenberg. He believed the church was selling something it had no right to sell: indulgences, papers that promised to shorten a soul's time in purgatory. He wrote ninety-five points for debate about those indulgences, and he mailed them to his archbishop. The story says he nailed them to a church door. What he did was mail them. The letter was printed, and the printing press did the rest. Within weeks, a local argument about indulgences had become a movement. And within a generation, that movement had split into families.
Here are the four families. The Lutherans, who kept the sacraments and the liturgy and rebuilt the faith on one doctrine. The Anglicans, who kept the bishops and the prayer book and walked a middle way. The Presbyterians, who rebuilt the church on the sovereignty of God and governed it by elders. And the Anabaptists, who said the whole thing had not gone far enough, and started over with believers only. I will tell each one the way its own people tell it, because each family deserves to be heard in its own words.
The first family is the Lutheran family, and it begins with a question that haunted Martin Luther. How is a sinner made right with God? Luther had tried the old answer. He had confessed, fasted, and punished his own body, and none of it gave him peace. Then he read the letter to the Romans, and one sentence broke the argument open. In the first chapter, verse seventeen, Paul writes, in the New International Version, "The righteous will live by faith." Luther read that sentence and understood it at last. A person is made right with God not by doing enough, and not by buying enough, but by trusting Christ. Paul says it again in his letter to the Ephesians, chapter two, verses eight and nine: "For it is by grace you have been saved, through faith, and this is not from yourselves, it is the gift of God, not by works, so that no one can boast." Grace alone. Faith alone. That is the Lutheran answer, and it is the foundation everything else in this family is built on.
Luther never meant to start a new church. He meant to reform the one he had. But the break came anyway, and the Lutherans had to say what they believed, in writing, so that no one could mistake it. In fifteen thirty, at the Diet of Augsburg, the Lutheran princes presented a confession of faith to the emperor. It was written mostly by Luther's friend and colleague, Philip Melanchthon, and it had twenty-eight articles: twenty-one on doctrine, and seven on the abuses the Lutherans wanted reformed. Fifty years later, in fifteen eighty, the Lutherans gathered all of their confessional writings into one book, the Book of Concord, and that book is still the binding statement of what Lutherans believe. Alongside it stands Luther's own Small Catechism, written in fifteen twenty-nine, a short book of questions and answers that taught ordinary families the faith, one household at a time.
The Lutherans kept more of the old church than any other Protestant family. They kept the liturgy, the vestments, and the church year. And they kept two sacraments, baptism and the Lord's Supper, because those are the two Christ himself commanded. But they understood them differently than Rome did. Baptism, for a Lutheran, is a means of grace. God acts through the water. That is why Lutherans baptize infants: the child receives what God gives, before the child can do anything at all. And in the Supper, Lutherans hold that Christ is truly present, in, with, and under the bread and the wine. The bread stays bread. The wine stays wine. And Christ is present in them, truly and really. That middle position, neither the Catholic teaching that the bread becomes the body, nor the memorial view that it is only a symbol, is the Lutheran signature. It is the family that reformed the doctrine and kept the worship.
The second family is the Anglican family, and it begins not with a monk, but with a king. Henry the Eighth of England wanted his marriage annulled. His wife, Catherine of Aragon, had given him no living son, and Henry wanted a new queen. The pope would not grant the annulment. So Henry took the matter into his own hands. In fifteen thirty-four, Parliament passed the Act of Supremacy, declaring the king the only supreme head on earth of the Church of England. The break with Rome was made by law, not by theology. Henry still believed almost everything the old church believed. He kept the Mass, the bishops, and the old doctrine. What changed was the name at the top. The pope was out. The king was in.
But the king's break opened a door, and others walked through it. After Henry died, his young son Edward the Sixth came to the throne, and the men around him were real reformers. The greatest of them was Thomas Cranmer, the Archbishop of Canterbury. Cranmer gave England something no other Protestant family had: a prayer book. The first Book of Common Prayer appeared in fifteen forty-nine, and it put the worship of the church into English, into words ordinary people could speak and understand. Morning prayer. Evening prayer. Baptism, marriage, burial, and the Lord's Supper, all in one book, all in the language of the people. The prayer book became the Anglican identity. When the Catholic queen Mary came to the throne, she burned Cranmer at the stake for it. But the book survived him, and it still defines Anglican worship today.
The settlement came under Henry's daughter Elizabeth. In fifteen fifty-nine, in the first year of her reign, Parliament passed two acts: the Act of Supremacy, which made the queen the supreme governor of the church, and the Act of Uniformity, which restored the prayer book as the only lawful form of worship. That settlement is the Anglican way. The church kept its bishops, in a line going back to the apostles. It kept its prayer book, and its ordered worship. And it stated its doctrine in the Thirty-Nine Articles, drawn up in fifteen sixty-three and given their final form in fifteen seventy-one. The Articles are deliberately moderate, written to hold a broad church together. That is the via media, the middle way: a church between Catholicism and Protestantism, holding elements of both, and refusing to be only one or the other.
One more Anglican deserves a mention, because he gave the settlement its mind. Richard Hooker, writing in the fifteen nineties, defended the church Elizabeth had built — not by saying Scripture, reason, and tradition were three equal authorities, as a later century would claim, but by saying Scripture alone is sufficient for everything necessary to salvation, and that the rest — bishops, prayer books, the king's authority over the church — are matters left to human wisdom. The famous three-legged stool was not Hooker's invention. It was built three centuries later, by men explaining Hooker to an age of biblical criticism. Hooker himself was a Reformer through and through — he simply believed the Spirit works through reason, learning, and public argument, not around them.
The third family is the Presbyterian family, and its father is John Calvin. Calvin was a Frenchman, a lawyer by training, who became the great theologian of the Reformation. In fifteen thirty-six, when he was only twenty-six years old, he published a small book in Basel, six chapters long, called the Institutes of the Christian Religion. It was meant as a handbook for persecuted French Protestants. Calvin kept revising it for the rest of his life. By the final edition, published in Geneva in fifteen fifty-nine, it had grown to four books and eighty chapters, a complete system of Christian doctrine. And Geneva became the model. Calvin built a city where the church disciplined its members, the pastors preached through the Bible book by book, and the whole of life, from the market to the magistrate, was ordered under the word of God.
At the center of Calvin's system stands one doctrine: the sovereignty of God. God decides, and man responds. Calvin taught that before the world was made, God chose those he would save, not because he foresaw anything good in them, but freely, by his own purpose. Paul puts it this way in his letter to the Ephesians, chapter one, verses four and five, in the New International Version: "For he chose us in him before the creation of the world to be holy and blameless in his sight. In love he predestined us for adoption to sonship through Jesus Christ." That teaching is called predestination, and it is the sharpest edge of the Presbyterian faith. It means salvation is God's work from first to last. No one contributes to it. No one earns it. And no one who is truly chosen can finally fall away, because God preserves his own. Those five points are total depravity, unconditional election, limited atonement, irresistible grace, and perseverance of the saints. But what matters is the shape of it: God alone saves, and the church is the company of those he has called.
Calvin's ideas traveled, and they traveled furthest to Scotland. John Knox had sat under Calvin's teaching in Geneva, and when he came home to Scotland in fifteen fifty-nine, he carried Geneva with him. In fifteen sixty, the Scottish Parliament broke with Rome, approved a new confession of faith, and built a church on Calvin's pattern. That church is governed not by bishops and not by congregations, but by elders in courts: the local session, the presbytery, the synod, and the General Assembly, each court answering to the one above it. And the doctrine of that church was finally written down in the Westminster Confession, finished in sixteen forty-six by an assembly of English theologians, and adopted by the Church of Scotland in sixteen forty-seven. Thirty-three chapters, covering everything from Scripture to the last judgment, and still the subordinate standard of Presbyterian churches around the world.
The fourth family is the Anabaptist family, and it begins with a quarrel inside the Reformation itself. In Zurich, a group of young reformers had followed Zwingli, the city's reformer. But they thought Zwingli had stopped too soon. He had reformed the doctrine, they said, and left the church itself untouched. The breaking point was baptism. On the twenty-first of January, fifteen twenty-five, in the house of Felix Manz, Conrad Grebel baptized George Blaurock, and Blaurock then baptized the others. They had all been baptized as infants, and now they were baptized again, as believers, on their own confession of faith. That is what the name means. Anabaptist means rebaptizer. Their enemies gave them the name as an insult, and it stuck. Their own argument came from the Acts of the Apostles, chapter two, verse thirty-eight, where Peter says, in the New International Version, "Repent and be baptized, every one of you, in the name of Jesus Christ for the forgiveness of your sins." Repentance first, then baptism. A believer's baptism, and only a believer's baptism.
Two years later, in fifteen twenty-seven, the Swiss Brethren met at Schleitheim, a small town on the northern border of Switzerland, and wrote down what they believed. The Schleitheim Confession has seven articles, and they draw a hard line. Believer's baptism only. The Lord's Supper as a memorial meal. The church disciplined by its own members. And then the three articles that made them dangerous: separation from the world, the refusal of the sword, and the refusal of the oath. The Anabaptists would not fight, would not serve as magistrates, and would not swear oaths. They would not mix the church with the state. In a world where every church was a state church, that was revolution. And the world answered the way it always answers revolution: with persecution.
The persecution came from both sides. The Catholics hunted them as heretics. The Protestants hunted them as rebels. Felix Manz was drowned in the river Limmat in fifteen twenty-seven, the first Anabaptist executed by a Protestant government. And yet the movement did not die. It found a shepherd in Menno Simons, a Dutch priest who left the old church in fifteen thirty-six and spent the rest of his life gathering the scattered, peaceful Anabaptists of the Netherlands and northern Germany. They took his name, and they are still called Mennonites today. The Anabaptists never became a great church. But their idea outlived them: that the church should be free, made of believers only, and separate from the state. The Baptists took that idea up. The Americans wrote it into law. And the free church, the church that no king commands, is the Anabaptist gift to the world.
So there are the four families. Luther answered Rome with faith alone, and kept the sacraments and the worship. Henry answered Rome with a king, and Cranmer and Elizabeth turned a royal break into a church of bishops and a prayer book. Calvin answered Rome with the sovereignty of God, and built a church of elders and confessions. And the Anabaptists answered Rome, and the Reformers too, with a free church of believers only. Four answers to one question, and each one still defines the church that gave it. Within a generation, the Peace of Augsburg, in fifteen fifty-five, wrote the first of these answers into law — each prince choosing the religion of his territory. A century later, the Peace of Westphalia, in sixteen forty-eight, wrote three of them into the law of the Empire: Catholic, Lutheran, and Reformed. Next time, those families cross the ocean. The Second Great Awakening makes American Protestantism, and the Baptists and the Methodists, the camp meetings and the circuit riders, take the revival to the frontier.
Now here is where I get Unfiltered.
The Protestants were divided among themselves from the earliest chapters of their existence and even engaged in violence among each other. This division and infighting is still occurring today over another hotly debated topic – the LGBTQ topic. As a Catholic, I possess social conservative values meaning that I do not agree with same-sex relationships or marriages. However, I have stated that I am willing to set my beliefs aside and do the work to understand my counterparts and their story better. This episode shines light that our Protestant brothers and sisters are every bit as imperfect as we are and looking to answer the same questions that we yearn to answer. The more I learn about their story, the better I can see their faith for the beauty that it is.
Thank you for listening to Joshua Unfiltered. And this is a value-for-value show. That means if you enjoyed what you heard, if you learned something new, if you received some form of value from listening, I kindly ask that you please share this show with someone you know. In the morning, and thank you for your courage.
History
Scripture (New International Version)
Source list revised November 12, 2026 — citations now point to the underlying works directly.