Joshua Unfiltered podcast cover art

Joshua Unfiltered

The show where we take the news of the moment and put it in a longer story, so it actually makes sense.

Hosted by Sir Joshua The Historian


Episode 010: The American Revival

November 11, 2026 · 15 minutes

The Reformation families cross the ocean, and the Second Great Awakening makes American Protestantism. From the concert of prayer in 1794 to the thousands who fell at Cane Ridge in 1801, Sir Joshua The Historian tells how the Baptists and the Methodists — two churches built for the frontier — carried the revival west: circuit riders, camp meetings, Charles Finney and the new measures, and a benevolent empire that took up temperance and reform. But both churches split over slavery, and that shadow falls across the whole story.

Theme music: "Americana" (intro) and "Deliberate Thought" (outro) by Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com), licensed under Creative Commons Attribution.


Full transcript

Welcome to Joshua Unfiltered. I'm Sir Joshua The Historian your host and guide. This is not the news of the moment. This is a lesson in history and religion, and we are going to walk through it slowly, so it actually makes sense.

Last time, we met the four families of the Reformation — Lutheran, Anglican, Presbyterian, Anabaptist — and we left them in Europe, their answers written into law at Augsburg and Westphalia. But the story did not stay in Europe. The families crossed the ocean, and on the American frontier they met something Europe never gave them: open land, no established church, and a people who chose their religion for themselves. What happened next was not a new reformation. It was a revival. And the revival made American Protestantism.

It began quietly, with prayer. In seventeen ninety-four, a group of ministers in Lebanon, Connecticut, agreed to pray together for a revival, at set times, in concert — and the prayer meetings spread from town to town. Andover Seminary, founded in eighteen eight, carried the same prayer into the next generation. But the revival that answered that prayer did not look quiet at all.

It begins in a field in Kentucky. In August, eighteen one, in Bourbon County, a Presbyterian minister named Barton Stone called his people together for a communion season — several days of preaching, prayer, and the Lord's Supper, the way the Scots had done it for generations. But this time the crowd did not go home. Word spread, and by the weekend ten to twenty-five thousand people had gathered at Cane Ridge — farmers, families, slaves and free, Presbyterians, Methodists, Baptists, and the merely curious — more people than lived in any town in Kentucky. They slept in wagons and under trees. They preached from stumps and wagons, day and night, for the better part of a week. And people fell down.

The falling was the thing nobody could explain and nobody could stop. Men and women dropped to the ground as if struck, lay still for hours, and rose weeping or shouting. Some jerked. Some laughed. Some barked like dogs. The preachers called them the exercises, and they took them as the work of the Spirit. The crowds called it the revival, and they came back for more. Within a few years, the camp meeting — a field, a stand, a preacher, and a crowd that stayed for days — had become the American way of doing religion. The Second Great Awakening had begun, and it would not stop for forty years.

But a revival is not a church. Somebody has to gather the converts, baptize them, marry them, bury them, and keep them. On the frontier, two churches did that work better than all the rest. The Baptists and the Methodists. They were not the oldest churches in America, and they were not the richest. But they were the ones built for the frontier, and by the time the revival ran its course, they were the two great American denominations.

The Baptists began with a simple idea, and they have never let go of it. The church is made of believers only, and baptism belongs to the believer. No infant baptism, no state church, no bishop telling a congregation what to believe. Each church governs itself, each soul stands before God on its own — the Baptists call it soul competency, the belief that every person is competent to answer God for themselves, and soul liberty, the freedom to do it without coercion. They had been in America since Roger Williams founded the first Baptist church in Providence in sixteen thirty-eight. But the Baptists who became America were the revival Baptists — Shubal Stearns at Sandy Creek in seventeen fifty-five, preaching in the Carolina backcountry, baptizing in the creeks, and sending out preachers who planted churches the way farmers plant corn.

The Baptist way fit the frontier because it asked so little of a convert and so little of a church. A preacher, a creek, and a congregation that chose its own pastor. No seminary required, no bishop's permission, no prayer book. By eighteen twenty, the Baptists and the Methodists had overtaken all the older churches in America. And then the Baptists did what every American denomination would eventually do: they split over slavery. In eighteen forty-five, Southern Baptists formed their own convention, after the northern mission board refused to appoint slaveholders as missionaries. The church of soul liberty had decided that a man's liberty could include owning another man. That is the shadow of this story, and we will come back to it.

The Methodists began with a man who could not sit still. John Wesley was an Anglican priest who preached in the fields of England because the churches would not have him. In seventeen thirty-eight, at a meeting on Aldersgate Street in London, he wrote in his journal that he felt his heart strangely warmed, and knew at last that Christ had taken away his sins. From that night, Wesley preached everywhere, to anyone who would listen, and he said the world was his parish. He organized his converts into small classes that met weekly, examined each other's souls, and held each other to the life. And he taught the way of salvation as three movements of one grace. Prevenient grace, the grace of God that reaches out to a person before that person ever reaches back. Justifying grace, the pardon of sins, received by faith alone. And sanctifying grace, the work of God in us — beginning with the new birth and carried all the way to entire sanctification, the belief that a Christian can be made perfect in love in this life. Along the way, the believer is given assurance, the witness of the Spirit that sins are forgiven, and the means of grace — prayer, the Scriptures, the Lord's Supper, and fasting — to walk in. And it is all free grace, for all people, lived out together in what Wesley called social holiness.

Wesley's church came to America in the seventeen seventies, and it found its man in Francis Asbury. Asbury landed in seventeen seventy-one and never went home. For forty-five years he rode the circuits on horseback, preaching in cabins, barns, and open fields, ordaining preachers, and holding the scattered societies together. The circuit rider was the Methodist invention that won the frontier: a preacher assigned not to one church but to a circuit of preaching points, riding from one to the next, month after month, year after year. Paul asks the question in his letter to the Romans, chapter ten, verse fourteen, in the New International Version: "And how can they hear without someone preaching to them?" The circuit rider was the answer. In seventeen eighty-four, at the Christmas Conference in Baltimore, the American Methodists became their own church, with Asbury and Thomas Coke as its first bishops, and a connectional system — churches bound together by conferences, from the local class meeting to the General Conference — that could hold a continent.

It worked. The Methodists grew faster than any church in America — a quarter of a million members in eighteen twenty, nearly half a million by eighteen twenty-nine, the largest denomination in the country. And like the Baptists, they split over slavery. In eighteen forty-four, the General Conference divided over Bishop Andrew, who owned slaves, and the southern churches walked out to form their own body. The revival had made the Methodists American, and America had made the Methodists divided.

So how did it work? The machinery of the revival was simple, and it was borrowed. The camp meeting came first — and the Presbyterians used it first, in the West, before the Methodists made it their own. By eighteen eleven, the Methodists were holding four hundred camp meetings, and Asbury estimated that three million Americans attended one that year — more than a quarter of the people in the country. A field near woods and water, a preacher's stand, tents and wagons in a circle, preaching day and night for days on end. In the towns, the camp meeting shrank into the protracted meeting, four days of preaching in a city church. Same fire, smaller field.

And then came the man everyone remembers, and almost everyone remembers wrong. Charles Finney was a lawyer turned preacher, and he preached like a lawyer before a jury — plain, direct, addressed to you, not to they. He began in the towns of upper New York, in the country historians call the Burned-over District — scorched by so much religious fire, from revivals to new religions, that the district was said to be burned over. He used what came to be called the new measures: the anxious bench, a front pew where the uncommitted sat through the sermon the way a witness sits through testimony; protracted meetings; women praying aloud in mixed meetings; plain, informal language in prayer; prayer by name for the lost; and the hasty admission of new converts to membership — preaching that aimed at a decision tonight. The story says Finney invented all of it. He did not. The new measures were Methodist practices first. The anxious bench was the Methodist altar call under another name — in use in New York City by eighteen six, standard by the eighteen tens. What Finney did was carry Methodist methods east, into the cities and the Presbyterian churches, and make them respectable for people who would never join a Methodist church. In eighteen twenty-seven, the older preachers called him to account at New Lebanon, and checked him for a season. In eighteen thirty and eighteen thirty-one, at Rochester, he reached the height of his powers — the whole city was involved, shopkeepers closing their businesses and urging people to attend — and he took up the anxious seat for good.

Finney said it plainly in his lectures on revivals: a revival was not a miracle, but the right use of proper means. In eighteen thirty-five, he left New York for Oberlin College in Ohio, where he taught and preached, and tied the revival to the great reforms of the day — temperance, and the fight against slavery — while warning that reform must never replace revival. And with Oberlin's president, Asa Mahan, he taught Christian perfection — Wesley's holiness, carried into a new century. The revival had become a technique, and Finney was its great technician.

And the revival did not stop at conversion. It organized. The converts built what they called the benevolent empire — Bible societies, tract societies, missionary societies, Sunday schools — an army of volunteers carrying the printed word into every new settlement. By eighteen twenty-eight, the American Tract Society had distributed five million tracts, one for every three people in the country. The revivalists took up reform the way they took up preaching. The temperance movement is the test case: in eighteen twenty, Americans drank four times as much spirits per person as they do today, and the drinking did not stop at the tavern door — it came home, and wives and children bore the worst of it, in violence and in want. The American Temperance Society, founded in eighteen twenty-six, claimed a million and a quarter members by eighteen thirty-four. By eighteen forty-five, drinking had been cut in half. Conversion had become a public project. Paul's command in the Gospel of Matthew, chapter twenty-eight, verse nineteen, in the New International Version — "Therefore go and make disciples of all nations" — had become a publishing house, a mission board, and a reform society.

And who was actually converting? Mostly young women. Three in five converts, in New England, between seventeen ninety-eight and eighteen twenty-six — young, unmarried, many of them working the new textile mills, their old place in the household gone and their future uncertain. The revival offered them what the world did not: a decision of their own, a community of sisters and brethren, and a purpose. In New England the revival did not look like Cane Ridge. It looked like a prayer meeting — restrained, serious, conversions that came gradually, in a still way. One young woman, frightened by the shouting at a camp meeting, wrote that she preferred her religion in a still way. Another, converted at Canton in eighteen sixteen, called it her second nativity. Jesus said it in the Gospel of John, chapter three, verse three, in the New International Version: "Very truly I tell you, no one can see the kingdom of God unless they are born again." For these young women, the new birth was also a new public life. They stood before their congregations to profess their faith, they organized the missionary societies, and they became leaders — Abby Kelley speaking against slavery and for a woman's right to preach. In a world that told women to be seen and not heard, the revival let them speak. And that speaking would carry, in time, into the education of women and the vote.

So there are the two great American denominations. The Baptists, who made the church a congregation of believers, and the Methodists, who made the church a circuit of riders. Between them, they took the revival to the frontier, and the frontier took it the rest of the way. But there is a shadow over this story, and it is the same shadow over both churches. They preached abolition and practiced segregation. Asbury and Thomas Coke petitioned the Virginia legislature against slavery, and a Methodist preacher named Freeborn Garrettson freed his own slaves and carried blank manumission papers to give away. And then the Methodists retreated — from antislavery, into segregated worship — and the Baptists split, and the Black Christians who had prayed in the same meetings built churches of their own. Next time, the American experiments — the movements the revival spun off, and the churches that carried Black self-determination. And the shadow, brought into the light.

Now here is where I get Unfiltered.

The majority of American Protestants fall into one of two distinct families following the Second Great Awakening – The Baptists or The Methodists. Even though there were other groups like the Presbyterians, these two denominations would boast the larger population of members. The Methodists, nearly 500,000 by eighteen twenty-nine. The Baptists, estimated at 250,000 at the same time. Even with this newfound unity in Faith, there would still be division and infighting. Both groups would split over slavery by 1845. A split that would foreshadow the coming War Between the States. The journey of the Reformation movement seems to follow a pattern – protest, separate, unify, repeat. This pattern is consistent over the first 300 years of history among the Protestant faith structure. At each junction there is one consistency that I observe and acknowledge – there are people, just like me, who want to live a better life in Christ's vision and grace. And just like the time periods we are discussing, there are groups in our current society that are propagating that same formula. And it is a formula for constant conflict, constant division, and a foundation of unfounded hatred towards one another.

Thank you for listening to Joshua Unfiltered. And this is a value-for-value show. That means if you enjoyed what you heard, if you learned something new, if you received some form of value from listening, I kindly ask that you please share this show with someone you know. In the morning, and thank you for your courage.


Sources

History

Scripture (New International Version)

Source list revised November 12, 2026 — citations now point to the underlying works directly.

Glossary of key terms → ← Back to the latest episodes