Joshua Unfiltered podcast cover art

Joshua Unfiltered

The show where we take the news of the moment and put it in a longer story, so it actually makes sense.

Hosted by Sir Joshua The Historian


Episode 011: The American Experiments

November 15, 2026 · 23 minutes

The revival's children strike out on their own. Sir Joshua The Historian walks through the American experiments: the African Methodist Episcopal Church, born in a walkout at St. George's and carried south into the heart of slavery; the Black Baptists who gathered into the National Baptist Convention; the Unitarians and Universalists, who reasoned their way beyond the creeds; Joseph Smith and the Latter-day Saints, a restoration built to outlive its prophet; the Restoration Movement's plea of no creed but Christ; and the Millerites, who waited for the end on a date certain — and then had to live past it.

Theme music: "Americana" (intro) and "Deliberate Thought" (outro) by Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com), licensed under Creative Commons Attribution.


Full transcript

Welcome to Joshua Unfiltered. I'm Sir Joshua The Historian your host and guide. This is not the news of the moment. This is a lesson in history and religion, and we are going to walk through it slowly, so it actually makes sense.

Last time, we left the revival with a shadow over it. The Baptists and the Methodists had preached abolition and practiced segregation. Asbury and Coke had petitioned the Virginia legislature against slavery, and Freeborn Garrettson had freed his own slaves and carried blank manumission papers to give away. And then the churches retreated, and the Black Christians who had prayed in the same meetings built churches of their own. Tonight, we bring that shadow into the light — and we follow the revival where it spun off in every direction at once. What the Second Great Awakening produced was not one American church, but a generation of experiments. Different steeples on the same frontier horizon, each one an answer to the same question: now that every American can choose their religion for themselves, what will they choose?

We start where the shadow falls hardest, because that is where the story is most American. In seventeen eighty-seven, in Philadelphia, a group of Black Methodists were praying at St. George's Methodist Church when the white trustees pulled them from their knees and told them to move to the gallery. Richard Allen and Absalom Jones walked out — and they did not come back.

Allen told the story himself in his memoir, and it deserves to be heard in his own voice. The Black worshippers had been sent up to the gallery, to seats above the ones they had always occupied below. The elder said, let us pray. And while Absalom Jones was still on his knees, a trustee took hold of him and pulled, and said, you must get up — you must not kneel here. Jones answered, wait until prayer is over, and I will get up and trouble you no more. When prayer ended, they all went out of the church in a body. Here is the sting in Allen's telling: those same Black members had subscribed their own money toward finishing St. George's — building the gallery, laying the new floors — and just as the house was made comfortable, they were ordered out of the comfort of worshipping in it. When the Methodist elder threatened to read them out of the church for daring to build one of their own, Allen demanded the rule they had broken. Show us, he said, where we have violated any law of discipline of the Methodist church. And then he said the sentence that could stand over this whole series: "If you deny us your name, you cannot seal up the Scriptures from us, and deny us a name in heaven. We believe heaven is free for all who worship in spirit and truth."

Allen built Bethel Church in seventeen ninety-four, a church of his own, and in eighteen sixteen the Black Methodist congregations gathered into their own denomination: the African Methodist Episcopal Church, the first independent Black denomination in America. Theologically, it was Methodist through and through — Wesley's grace, Wesley's discipline, Wesley's classes. But it was Black-led, Black-owned, and Black-governed, and that made all the difference. The AME Church says it plainly to this day, in its own statement of beliefs: the split was not the result of doctrinal differences. It was the result of intolerance, based on the color of a man's skin. The AME exists because white Methodists excluded Black worshippers even while they supported abolition. Opposing slavery and practicing racial equality were two different things, and the churches of that era mostly managed the first while failing the second.

And the church Allen built did not stay in Philadelphia. It carried south, into the heart of slavery itself. At Charleston, the preacher Morris Brown gathered the Black Methodists into a congregation of their own — Emanuel Church, Mother Emanuel, the oldest AME church in the South. Among its founders was Denmark Vesey, a carpenter who had bought his own freedom. In eighteen twenty-two, Vesey planned the boldest answer slavery ever drew in that city: on July fourteenth, the enslaved would rise, fight their way to the docks, and sail for Haiti, and freedom. The plot was betrayed before it began. Vesey was hanged on July second, the church was burned, and Brown was driven out of the state. The congregation rebuilt, and worshipped on — until eighteen thirty-four, when South Carolina law closed the Black churches, and Mother Emanuel's people worshipped in secret for thirty years, until freedom came in eighteen sixty-five. Sit with that a moment. Outlawed by the state, underground for a generation, and still standing when the war ended. The church born in a walkout had learned how to survive anything.

The Black Baptists walked the same road. Black Baptist churches date to the seventeen seventies, and to Savannah in seventeen eighty-eight, and for a century they worshipped under white oversight or on the margins of white churches. In eighteen ninety-five, three Black Baptist national bodies merged at Atlanta into the National Baptist Convention, USA — the largest predominantly Black Christian denomination in America, about seven and a half million members claimed, headquartered at Nashville. In nineteen sixty-one it split again, over the presidency and over direct-action tactics, and Martin Luther King Junior's allies left to form the Progressive National Baptist Convention. Read those dates together and the pattern is plain. The Black church was not a footnote to American Protestantism. By eighteen fifty there were a hundred sixty-six thousand six hundred ninety Black Methodists, about fifteen percent of the whole Methodist church — and in the Southern church, more than a quarter of its membership. Paul writes it in his letter to the Galatians, chapter three, verse twenty-eight, in the New International Version: "There is neither Jew nor Gentile, neither slave nor free, nor is there male and female, for you are all one in Christ Jesus." The Black church took that verse seriously enough to build a church on it, when the white churches would not live it.

Now turn the other way, to the churches that questioned the creed itself. In the seventeen seventies, a preacher named John Murray arrived in America teaching that Christ died for all and all would finally be saved — universal salvation. The Universalists gathered around that hope, and in eighteen three they wrote it down in the Winchester Profession of Faith: one God, "whose nature is Love," who would "finally restore the whole family of mankind to holiness and happiness." Their great theologian, Hosea Ballou, pressed that hope into an argument in eighteen five. Sin, he said, is finite, because man is finite, and a finite sin cannot owe an infinite debt. God was not the unreconciled party, waiting to be appeased. Mankind was. Christ did not change the heart of God toward man; he revealed the love of God and reconciled man to God. At the same time, in Boston, the old Congregational churches were quietly becoming Unitarian. King's Chapel revised its prayer book in seventeen eighty-five, cutting out the Trinity. In eighteen nineteen, William Ellery Channing preached the sermon that named the movement, "Unitarian Christianity," and in eighteen twenty-five the American Unitarian Association was formed. Channing preached from First Thessalonians, chapter five, verse twenty-one: "Prove all things; hold fast that which is good." Those are the words of the King James Bible, and they were his method as much as his text. The Bible, he said, is a book written for men, in the language of men, and reason must be exercised on it perpetually, comparing and inferring, looking beyond the letter to the spirit. The Unitarians kept the Bible and the moral teaching of Jesus, but they rejected the Trinity and the divinity of Christ. For them, Jesus was the great teacher and example, not God made flesh.

Those questions did not begin in America. In fifteen fifty-three, Michael Servetus was burned at Geneva after denying the Trinity and infant baptism. Two generations later, the Polish Brethren who followed Faustus Socinus published the Racovian Catechism, teaching that Christ was by nature truly a man, and that his death was not a payment offered to satisfy divine justice. In Europe, arguments like these could end in exile, prison, or fire. In America, they could become sermons, professions of faith, and voluntary churches.

Here is why that matters. The Nicene Creed, written in 325 A.D., had been the common inheritance of every family we have met — Lutheran, Anglican, Presbyterian, Anabaptist, Baptist, Methodist. All of them affirmed one God in three persons. The Unitarians were the first American movement to say no to that creed, and to say it openly, in the middle of the revival. The same question Nicaea answered came back in the seventeen hundreds, and this time the answer was different. The revival had taught Americans to read the Bible for themselves and to trust their own conscience. The Unitarians took that lesson further than the revivalists intended. If every soul is competent before God, then every soul may judge the creed too. The two movements merged in nineteen sixty-one, but their question never went away: who decides what a Christian must believe — the creed, the church, or the conscience?

The next experiment did not argue with the creed. It went around it. In eighteen twenty, a young man named Joseph Smith said he had seen God the Father and Jesus Christ in a grove near Palmyra, New York, and been told that all the churches were wrong. Ten years later he published the Book of Mormon, and on April sixth, eighteen thirty, he organized the Church of Christ at Fayette, New York. The claim was not reform. It was restoration. The true church, the Saints said, had fallen away in a Great Apostasy, and God was restoring it — new scripture, new prophets, new priesthood authority — through Smith. That is why the Latter-day Saints do not call themselves Protestants, and why this episode does not call them Protestants either. A Protestant reforms the church. A restorationist says the church was lost and must be given back.

The setting was the revival itself. Western New York was so scorched by revivals that people later called it the burned-over district, and the records bear the name out. In eighteen twenty the Presbyterians of the Geneva Presbytery reported two hundred new members, more than in any former year, and the Methodist circuit at Lyons nearly doubled. Smith grew up in that air, drawn toward the Methodists, raised partly among Presbyterians — and his own account of the grove grew as he grew into it. His first written account, in eighteen thirty-two, is mostly about his sins: a boy convicted and distressed, and the Lord appearing to tell him that his sins were forgiven. Richard Bushman, the Latter-day Saint historian who wrote the standard biography of Smith, puts it this way: the first act of the Restoration was to put the soul of the Lord's prophet into order. The famous account of eighteen thirty-eight asks the other question — which church is true — and answers, none of them. Both accounts stand in the open today, differences and all, in the church's own published essays.

Even the Book of Mormon refuses the American script. Its peoples are not revolutionaries throwing off a king. They flee bondage, and God delivers them — Exodus, not seventeen seventy-six — and when its peoples do choose kings, they choose them by the voice of the people. Too much Americana is missing, Bushman writes; the book runs on Hebrew templates, strangely distant from the country that produced it. And what came through Smith came in a voice no other American prophet used: the revelations speak as God himself, in the first person, with no arguments and no proof texts, leaving the hearer to decide. The voice rebukes the prophet as readily as it exalts him — after Smith lost the first hundred sixteen pages of the translation, the revelation that followed was addressed entirely against Smith himself. Smith hungered for the ancient world, too, but on his own road. In Kirtland he hired a Jewish teacher, Joshua Seixas, and set his elders to studying Hebrew, and he worked at a grammar of Egyptian from papyri that arrived with a traveling mummy exhibition — chasing what men of his age called the primal tongue, a language in which truth could be stated so plainly that division would dissolve.

Then the gathering collided with Missouri. Smith declared that Zion would rise in Jackson County, and Missouri answered with mobs. In eighteen thirty-three the Mormon printing press was destroyed and some twelve hundred Saints were driven across the river. The mobs said it was about slaves and Indians. The record says it was about power — twelve hundred Saints, a third of the county, voting as one people, in a county God had told them was theirs. The legislature carved out Caldwell County as a Mormon refuge, and it failed within two years: the Saints spilled past its borders, an election-day riot lit the fuse in eighteen thirty-eight. That summer Sidney Rigdon had preached a war of extermination against the church's enemies. In October, Governor Lilburn Boggs threw the word back at them, and issued the order that still stands alone in American history. The Mormons, he wrote, must be treated as enemies, and must be exterminated or driven from the state. Three days later, on October thirtieth, a mob fell on the settlement at Haun's Mill and killed seventeen men and boys, the youngest nine years old. Some eight thousand Saints fled the state in winter, ragged and stripped of their property. Smith, writing from a cell in Liberty Jail, cried out the question that became scripture: O God, where art thou? In Doctrine and Covenants, section one hundred twenty-one. The Saints did not only suffer the violence; some dealt it. A paramilitary band, the Danites, raided and burned in return, and the church's own published history names that plainly today, and names the persecutions plainly too — context that explains, in its own words, but does not excuse.

Illinois welcomed them, and then Illinois repeated Missouri. At Nauvoo the Saints built a city that rivaled Chicago, and Smith stood at its center — mayor, chief justice, commander of its militia — and in eighteen forty-four he ran for president of the United States. When a dissenting newspaper attacked him, he ordered its press destroyed, and that act lit the final fuse. On June twenty-seventh, eighteen forty-four, a mob shot Joseph and Hyrum Smith dead in the jail at Carthage. And here is what no one predicted: the movement did not die with its prophet. Smith had spent fourteen years putting his own charisma into offices — apostles, keys, councils, a church that ran by written order — and sharing the gift of revelation down through the ranks, while his own scripture, written from that Liberty cell, bound all power to persuasion, long-suffering, gentleness, and love unfeigned. So when the prophet fell, the office stood. The Saints sustained Brigham Young by the keys of that office, walked out of Nauvoo in eighteen forty-six, and reached the valley of the Great Salt Lake in eighteen forty-seven, on soil that was not yet the United States. Bushman calls the arrangement a charismatic bureaucracy. Whatever else it was, it was built to survive. It did.

Survival was not peace. Ten years after reaching the valley, with a federal army marching on Utah and the old persecutions fresh in memory, local Mormon militiamen in southern Utah lured an Arkansas wagon train out of its circle under a false flag of truce at Mountain Meadows and murdered one hundred twenty men, women, and children. The church's own history calls it what President Henry Eyring called it: a terrible and inexcusable departure from Christian teaching. The church's own historians conclude that Brigham Young did not order it. Will Bagley, the massacre's other great historian, argued to this day that he did. And when Mormon missionaries carried the restored gospel into the South after the Civil War, the violence followed them there — Joseph Standing murdered in Georgia in eighteen seventy-nine, three more Saints killed at Cane Creek, Tennessee, in eighteen eighty-four, more than three hundred violent incidents in the region's record. Hold the whole of it at once: a people named for extermination in a governor's order on one page, and the authors of a massacre on another. That is not a contradiction the record lets us escape. It is the record. Whatever a listener believes about their claims, the pattern is unmistakable: the revival's freedom to seek God for yourself, carried to its furthest edge — a new scripture, a new prophet, a church built to outlive its founder — and a people willing to walk a thousand miles for it.

Back on the frontier, two preachers from the revival itself tried a different answer. Barton Stone, the Presbyterian who had hosted Cane Ridge, and Alexander Campbell, a Scotch-Irish immigrant, both concluded that the denominations were the problem. Creeds divided Christians, they said, so throw out the creeds. Their motto was simple: no creed but Christ, no book but the Bible. Stone's Christians and Campbell's Disciples met at Lexington, Kentucky, in eighteen thirty-two and shook hands on a union — no merger papers, no bishops, just a shared commitment to the New Testament pattern: believer's baptism by immersion, the Lord's Supper every Sunday, and each congregation governing itself. They called it the Restoration Movement, and the name was the program: restore the church of the first century, and the divisions of the centuries will fall away. It did not quite work that way — the movement itself later divided into three bodies — but its instinct shaped American religion for a century. The non-denominational church on the corner, the pastor who says "we just preach the Bible," the communion table open every week: that is Stone and Campbell, still speaking.

And then there were the Millerites, the experiment that ended in a date. William Miller, a Baptist farmer turned preacher, read the prophecies of Daniel and concluded that Christ would return in eighteen forty-four. Tens of thousands believed him. They sold farms, they left crops in the field, they waited on rooftops and in meetinghouses for the end. October twenty-second, eighteen forty-four, came and went, and nothing happened. The Great Disappointment broke the movement into pieces. A general conference at Albany in the spring of eighteen forty-five failed to hold them together. But some of the pieces held. A small group concluded that the date was right and the event was wrong — that in eighteen forty-four Christ had entered the heavenly sanctuary, not returned to earth — and in eighteen sixty-three they organized at Battle Creek as the Seventh-day Adventist Church. They kept the Saturday Sabbath, they taught that the dead sleep until the resurrection, and they listened to the prophetic gift they saw in Ellen White. The Millerites are the warning inside the experiments: a movement built on a date can survive the date being wrong, but only if it can admit what happened and keep walking.

So there they are, five experiments on one horizon. The Black church, built because the revival's promise stopped at the color line. The Unitarians and Universalists, who questioned the creed the revival inherited. The Saints, who claimed the church had been lost and must be restored. The Restoration Movement, which tried to throw out the creeds and start over from the Bible alone. And the Millerites, who set a date for the end and had to live past it. None of them fit the denominational mold. All of them were American — voluntary, chosen, built by people who believed they could start again.

And they spread the same way the revival spread: by choice, not by law. No bishop assigned them, no legislature funded them. They printed tracts, they sent out itinerant preachers, they formed voluntary societies, and they built meetinghouses where the people were. Philadelphia alone had thirty-four places of worship for eighteen sects — one for every eighteen hundred seventy-six people. The number of clergymen in America tripled in thirty years, from one in fifteen hundred people at the Revolution to one in five hundred. The denominational smorgasbord, the historians call it: Seventh Day Baptists, Free Will Baptists, Campbellites, Hicksite Quakers, Mormons, Unitarians, Universalists, all in the same towns, all competing for the same souls, all surviving on the free choice of their members. That is the experiment underneath the experiments. Religion in America would no longer be inherited. It would be chosen, week by week, dollar by dollar, soul by soul.

And here is the thread that ties them together. In Europe, religion was settled by territory: the ruler chose, and the people followed. In America, the settlement was the opposite. No established church, no ruler's religion, no creed enforced by law. The revival had already proved that a person could choose. These experiments proved that a people could choose, too — and that the choice would not always be the one the older churches expected. The shadow is still there. The Black church exists because the white church failed its own gospel. But the light is there as well. Every one of these movements was somebody's act of conscience, somebody deciding that the faith they had been handed was not the faith they would keep, and building something new in its place. Next time, the Third Awakening — the decades when the experiments became institutions, the Social Gospel met the city, and a Baptist minister named Francis Bellamy wrote a pledge for schoolchildren that would outlive them all.

Now here is where I get Unfiltered.

The social issues of the revival movement – the Abolition and Temperance movements – were carried by sincere people, but in the hands of these rapidly growing religious organizations, they too often became advertising campaigns to garner membership. Our episode today discussed the role that slavery played in the further splintering of the several denominations of the Protestant faith, primarily the Methodists and the Baptists. While Abolition was a chief social issue for the revival movement, it did not carry with it the equal treatment of Blacks within their newly established churches. And that statement is telling, these reformed Protestant branches of Christianity that spent numerous years and with a great many people organizing their faith would immediately cast out their own members based on the color of their skin. The unmistakable hypocrisy of their actions versus their pronounced beliefs is self-evident. Again and again in the early American republic, Christian bodies fought from within, split apart, and then gathered again around a different likeness. That pattern was not an interruption of American Christianity. It was one of its founding patterns.

Thank you for listening to Joshua Unfiltered. And this is a value-for-value show. That means if you enjoyed what you heard, if you learned something new, if you received some form of value from listening, I kindly ask that you please share this show with someone you know. In the morning, and thank you for your courage.


Sources

The African Methodist Episcopal Church, in its own words

The Black church and Charleston

The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, in its own words

Richard L. Bushman and the Missouri record

Unitarian and Universalist sources

Coursework and study

Scripture

Glossary of key terms → ← Back to the latest episodes