Joshua Unfiltered podcast cover art

Joshua Unfiltered

The show where we take the news of the moment and put it in a longer story, so it actually makes sense.

Hosted by Sir Joshua The Historian


Episode 012: The Third Awakening

November 19, 2026 · 21 minutes

The Third Awakening closes the Denominations Series. Sir Joshua The Historian walks from the Fulton Street prayer meeting of 1857 — businessmen praying at noon while the banks failed — through Moody and Sankey's managed revival, to the fork where the age's faith divided: Carnegie's Gospel of Wealth against the Social Gospel of Gladden and Rauschenbusch. At the center stands Francis Bellamy, the Christian socialist minister who lost his pulpit and wrote the Pledge of Allegiance — and the salute that went with it. Then the other fork: holiness, Darby and Scofield's dispensations, Azusa Street, and the fracture of fundamentalism and modernism, before the long road lands at Calvary Chapel and the non-denominational church.

Theme music: "Americana" (intro) and "Deliberate Thought" (outro) by Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com), licensed under Creative Commons Attribution.


Full transcript

Welcome to Joshua Unfiltered. I'm Sir Joshua The Historian your host and guide. This is not the news of the moment. This is a lesson in history and religion, and we are going to walk through it slowly, so it actually makes sense.

Last time, the experiments. Tonight, what the experiments grew into. The First Great Awakening was a fire season — a few years, a few preachers, one flame front moving through the colonies. The Second was a generation of camp meetings that remade the map. The Third was neither. It has no single summer and no single preacher. It came in segments, spread across fifty years and more — a prayer meeting here, a city campaign there, a new movement rising just as an older one settled into an institution. If the first two awakenings were foundations poured all at once, the third was a house built room by room, over decades, by builders who did not always agree on the plans. And its most famous product is not a denomination at all. It is thirty-one words that American schoolchildren recite every morning, written by a Baptist minister who had been pushed out of his pulpit. We will get to him. First, the prayer meeting that started it.

In the autumn of eighteen fifty-seven, the American economy fell off a cliff. Banks failed, railroads failed, and thousands of businesses closed their doors. And the churches were in no shape to answer it — religious life had been declining for fifteen years, soured in part by the Millerite disappointment of eighteen forty-four, when the predicted end had not come and even churches that had nothing to do with the prediction were mocked for it. In New York City, the North Dutch Church on Fulton Street had hired a lay missionary named Jeremiah Lanphier — a merchant of forty-nine who had given up his trade to knock on doors for a dying church, for less than a thousand dollars a year. After three months of visits that brought almost no one in, he did a simple thing. He invited the businessmen of the district to pray at noon. His placard read: "Prayer Meeting from twelve to one o'clock. Stop five, ten, or twenty minutes, or the whole hour, as your time admits." The first meeting, on September twenty-third, eighteen fifty-seven, drew six men — and Lanphier waited half an hour alone before the first of them came up the stairs. Within weeks the room was full, then the church was full, then churches across the city were opening at noon, and the meetings spread — Philadelphia, Boston, Chicago, town after town — businessmen in their working clothes, praying on their lunch hour, in the middle of a financial panic. They kept order with a posted rule: no prayer and no exhortation longer than five minutes, so that every man had his turn. There was no star preacher. There was barely an organization. Clerks and merchants ran it themselves. Nor was Fulton Street the only fire laid that year. That summer, across the border in Canada, Walter Palmer and his wife Phoebe — whose New York Tuesday Meetings had been teaching holiness for twenty years — held camp meetings through Ontario, and at Hamilton alone some six hundred people professed faith before the Palmers moved on. The historian Timothy Smith documented prayer meetings rising in town after town that same year; Fulton Street was the one that caught the country's eye. Even Henry Ward Beecher lent his voice, leading three thousand in devotions at Burton's Theater, close enough to hear the singing of an overflow prayer meeting in the barroom next door — and by the spring of eighteen fifty-eight the newspapers were fighting over the story, until Horace Greeley's Tribune devoted an entire edition to the revival. Finney caught the general impression in one sentence: "We have had instruction until we are hardened; it is now time for us to pray." By some estimates a million people were converted before the fires cooled. Historians call it the Businessmen's Revival, or the Prayer Meeting Revival, and it is the first segment of the Third Awakening: revival with no camp meeting, no frontier, and no celebrity — just laymen, a lunch hour, and a crisis.

The next segment had a celebrity — and the first segment had made him. Dwight Moody had been a young Chicago shoe salesman in the prayer meeting years: converted in a Boston stockroom in eighteen fifty-five, and formed in Chicago's own share of the revival, doing the YMCA's grunt work — sweeping, errand-running, whatever was needed — while the businessmen prayed at noon. A decade and more later he heard a call of his own, and with the singer Ira Sankey beside him he took the revival into the great cities — first Britain, then home again — and ran it like the businesses his audiences worked in. Advance teams arrived before he did. Advertising filled the papers. Great halls were rented, choirs were drilled, inquiry rooms were staffed so that no seeking soul left without a conversation. And the singing was half the machinery. Sankey's gift was the simple setting — hymns a crowd of thousands could learn on the spot — and his Gospel Hymns songbooks sold by the hundreds of thousands. He became the model that every evangelistic singer after him followed. Finney had taught America that a revival was not a miracle but the right use of proper means. Moody industrialized the means. Under Moody, revival stopped being an event that happened to a town and became an institution that a city could schedule. That is the second segment: the awakening learns management. And Moody's line ran straight into the next century — Billy Sunday, a former professional ballplayer, inherited his plain proclamation and his song-led crowds, and carried the managed revival to the biggest audiences of the nineteen tens.

But the city was asking a question the camp meeting never had to answer. The revival converts went home to tenements, to factory floors, to fourteen-hour days and child labor and strikes met with clubs. And out of that question, the Third Awakening forked. One road answered with the Gospel of Wealth — Andrew Carnegie gave it the name in eighteen eighty-nine — the teaching that riches were the natural reward of the fit, and that the wealthy man was a trustee of his surplus for the public good. Against it rose the other answer, and the movement that gives this era its second name: the Social Gospel. Washington Gladden, a Congregational minister in Ohio, argued that Christianity had to be applied — to wages, to housing, to the whole industrial order — or it was not being preached at all. Walter Rauschenbusch, a German Baptist pastor who spent eleven years preaching in Hell's Kitchen in New York, wrote the movement's great book, Christianity and the Social Crisis, in nineteen seven. Their text could have been the prophet Micah, chapter six, verse eight, in the New International Version: act justly, love mercy, walk humbly with your God. The kingdom of God, the Social Gospel preachers said, was not only a heaven to die into. It was a city to build, here, with clean water and honest wages and no children in the mills.

And here is what stung them into action. In eighteen forty-eight, nine years before Lanphier's prayer meeting, Marx and Engels had published The Communist Manifesto — and in it, they had dismissed Christian Socialism in one sentence, as the holy water with which the priest consecrates the heart-burnings of the aristocrat. The Manifesto had no use for the church, and no plan to infiltrate it — that charge belongs to later voices, and we name them when we use them. But the movement the Manifesto served was growing in the factory districts, and the churches could feel their people drifting toward it. One historian of the Social Gospel, Charles Howard Hopkins, put it plainly: socialism was the midwife and nurse to the Social Gospel, and no single force so stung American Protestantism into social action as did this gadfly of capitalism. The fork, in other words, was a contest — for the workingman's soul, between the church, the union hall, and the Manifesto.

Now meet the cousins. In eighteen eighty-eight, Edward Bellamy published a novel called Looking Backward, in which a Boston man sleeps and wakes in the year two thousand to find industry nationalized, poverty abolished, and every citizen maintained from cradle to grave. It became one of the century's best-selling books, and it spawned a political movement whose members called themselves Nationalists — their word for the nationalization of industry, the state owning the great machines for the common good. Edward's hope had old revival roots: postmillennial hope, the belief that the kingdom comes gradually as the church does its work, and the perfectionism Finney had preached — human nature not so much depraved as badly arranged, and fixable when the arrangements change. His cousin Francis carried that same hope into a pulpit. Francis Bellamy was a Baptist minister at Bethany Baptist Church in Boston, and he preached the social hope plainly enough that in eighteen ninety-one the pressure of his own congregation pushed him out of it. The banished minister needed work. He took a job at a children's magazine, The Youth's Companion — and there, a salesman's errand handed him immortality.

The magazine was running a campaign to sell American flags to schools, and planning a national Columbus Day celebration for the four hundredth anniversary of the voyage, with James Upham, the executive who ran the flag program, determined that every schoolhouse in the republic would raise a flag that day. Bellamy chaired the committee that wrote the program — and for it, he composed a pledge for the schoolchildren to recite as the flags went up. It was published in the magazine on September eighth, eighteen ninety-two, and on October twelfth, eighteen ninety-two, children across the country spoke it for the first time. Hear the original words, all twenty-two of them: "I pledge allegiance to my Flag and the Republic for which it stands, one nation, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all." No United States of America — those words replaced "my Flag" in nineteen twenty-three and nineteen twenty-four. And no "under God" — that arrived in nineteen fifty-four, in the middle of a different cold war, after a campaign by the Knights of Columbus, signed into law by President Eisenhower on Flag Day. The pledge most Americans recite today is the eighteen ninety-two original with two additions, each one a fingerprint of the era that pressed it in.

And then there is the salute. Bellamy prescribed gestures to go with the words, and the directions survive in print — The Journal of Education published them in full in January nineteen eighteen. The children began with the right hand lifted, palm downward, to a line with the forehead and close to it — a soldier's salute — and standing thus, all repeated the pledge together, slowly. At the words "to my Flag," the right hand was extended gracefully, palm upward, towards the flag, and remained in that gesture to the end of the affirmation — whereupon all hands immediately dropped to the side. The photographs survive — schoolrooms in eighteen ninety-nine, a great schoolyard in nineteen fifteen, classrooms in nineteen forty-one — rows of American children with right arms stretched out to the flag. Within a few years of those last photographs, that gesture had become the salute of fascist Europe, and in nineteen forty-two the United States Congress quietly changed the pledge's salute to the hand over the heart. The change belongs in this episode because the resemblance is the history: a gesture invented for American schoolchildren in eighteen ninety-two had to be retired fifty years later because the world had filled it with a meaning no one in that schoolroom could have imagined.

The pledge was contested from the beginning. Jehovah's Witness families taught their children that saluting a flag was idolatry, and their children were expelled for refusing. In nineteen forty, in Minersville School District against Gobitis, the Supreme Court upheld the expulsions. Three years later the Court reversed itself. In West Virginia against Barnette, decided on Flag Day, nineteen forty-three, Justice Robert Jackson wrote the sentence that still guards the schoolroom door: if there is any fixed star in our constitutional constellation, it is that no official, high or petty, can prescribe what shall be orthodox in politics, nationalism, religion, or other matters of opinion. And the pledge's own words carried the deepest ruling of all, though no court wrote it into the pledge. After the Civil War, in Texas against White, the Court held that Texas had never left the Union at all — that the Union was perpetual and indissoluble. Justice Antonin Scalia, asked in two thousand six whether a state could secede, answered that the question was settled, and reached for the schoolroom to prove it: hence, he wrote, in the Pledge of Allegiance, "one Nation, indivisible." A magazine staffer's sentence had become the republic's shorthand for its own survival.

So hold the whole of Francis Bellamy fairly, because that is the rule of this series. He was a Christian socialist, and the Manifesto would not have claimed him. He was a minister who lost his pulpit for his sermons, and a man who meant every word of "liberty and justice for all" as a promise the republic had not yet kept. The pledge is not a prayer. It was written as a civic ritual, for a school celebration, inside a flag campaign — and it is also the Third Awakening's hope in miniature: a shared loyalty, taught to children, that might bind a divided nation into one people. That a pledge could do that work — that words recited together could form a citizen — is the Social Gospel's faith carried into the classroom. Why it is never taught that way in school is a question this show has asked before.

While one fork of the awakening marched into the city, the other fork marched toward the end of the age. The holiness movement took Wesley's entire sanctification out of Methodism and carried it everywhere — Phoebe Palmer's Tuesday Meetings in New York had been teaching a shorter way to holiness since before the Civil War, and after it the teaching formed churches of its own, the Church of the Nazarene among them, organized in nineteen oh eight. Alongside holiness came a new way of reading prophecy. John Nelson Darby, an Irish preacher, taught that history runs in distinct ages, dispensations, and that the church and Israel stand on separate tracks in God's plan — and in nineteen oh nine the Scofield Reference Bible printed that system in the margins of the page itself, so that a generation of American Christians absorbed it without ever knowing they were learning a system at all. Scofield revised it in nineteen seventeen, and it became Oxford University Press's first book to sell a million copies — its sales kept climbing through the Great Depression. Where the Social Gospel was postmillennial — build the kingdom, and Christ will crown it — the new prophecy teaching was premillennial: the world worsens, the King returns, and the faithful watch and wait. Two forks, two futures, one awakening.

And then the awakening exploded. In nineteen oh one, in Topeka, Kansas, students of a preacher named Charles Parham concluded from the book of Acts that speaking in tongues was the Bible evidence of baptism in the Holy Spirit. Five years later the fire reached Los Angeles, carried by William Seymour, a Black preacher, the son of freed slaves, who had learned Parham's teaching in Houston sitting in a hallway, listening through the doorway, because Texas law would not let him sit in the classroom with white students. In a former stable on Azusa Street, beginning in April of nineteen oh six, Seymour led meetings where the segregated nation's rules simply stopped applying: Black and white, men and women, rich and poor, praying and testifying together, in a city and a country built on keeping them apart. Visitors carried it home like coals in a bucket. Missionaries carried it overseas within the year. The movement those meetings named — Pentecostalism — is today, with its charismatic kin, the largest single current in world Christianity, numbering in the hundreds of millions. The Third Awakening's most explosive export began in a rented stable, led by a man the awakening's own country would not seat in a classroom.

Inevitably, the forks became a fracture. In the seminaries and the great urban pulpits, a modernist party argued that the faith had to be restated for an age of Darwin and biblical criticism — Harry Emerson Fosdick preached its manifesto in nineteen twenty-two, a sermon titled "Shall the Fundamentalists Win?" The other party took its name from a publishing project: The Fundamentals, twelve volumes of essays defending the faith once delivered, financed by two California oilmen, the Stewart brothers, and mailed free, by the million, to pastors and missionaries around the world. In nineteen twenty a Baptist editor, Curtis Lee Laws, coined the name for the people rallying to it: those who still clung to the great fundamentals, and meant to do battle royal for them, would be called fundamentalists. And it was a coalition as much as a party: revivalists in Sunday's line, dispensationalists with their Scofield Bibles, holiness preachers, and confessional scholars — people who agreed on little else agreed that the fundamentals were not negotiable. Fundamentalists and modernists fought for the denominations machinery — and in the summer of nineteen twenty-five the fight became a spectacle the whole nation watched, in a courtroom in Dayton, Tennessee, where a young teacher named John Scopes stood trial for teaching evolution, with William Jennings Bryan, three times a candidate for president, arguing for the prosecution, and Clarence Darrow for the defense. Scopes was convicted, and the conviction was later set aside on a technicality — but the verdict the newspapers rendered lasted longer than the legal one. The fundamentalists withdrew from the fight for the big denominations and built a world of their own instead: Bible institutes, independent missions, publishing houses, seminaries. The party's sharpest mind, J. Gresham Machen of Princeton, had already written its case in nineteen twenty-three, in Christianity and Liberalism: liberalism, he argued, was not a form of Christianity at all, but a different religion borrowing its name. In nineteen twenty-nine he left Princeton and founded Westminster Seminary to train men for the other side. The split of the nineteen twenties is the second hinge of modern American Protestantism, and the walls built then are standing yet.

Which brings the series home. After the Second World War, the energy drained steadily out of the denominational headquarters and into everything else — parachurch ministries, independent missions, and finally the independent church itself. In the nineteen sixties and seventies the landing became visible: a small Costa Mesa congregation called Calvary Chapel, under a pastor named Chuck Smith, threw its doors open to the barefoot Jesus People. Smith took the young converts into his own home, and in nineteen sixty-eight he brought a hippie evangelist named Lonnie Frisbee into the work, to live and minister among them. Thousands of congregations copied the pattern — no denomination on the sign, no creed on the door, a pastor, a Bible, a band, and a building full of people who chose to be there. The non-denominational church is where the Third Awakening's long segmentation finally lands: the marketplace of choice that the experiments of eighteen forty-four opened, become the default setting of American religion.

Look back down the road we have walked in these five lessons. One protest at Speyer became four families at the Reformation, two great denominations in the American revival, then experiments in every direction, then segments, forks, and fractures across fifty years — and at every junction, the pattern we named in the last episode but one: protest, separate, unify, repeat. Fourteen traditions stand on the timeline where one church stood in fifteen seventeen. Some of that is loss. Some of it is the price of a faith that free people keep choosing for themselves, week by week, in a country that settled the question Augsburg and Westphalia settled by the sword, and settled it instead by the conscience. That is the lesson of the Third Awakening, and of the series: the awakenings built American Protestantism, and the choosing never stopped. It has not stopped yet.

Now here is where I get Unfiltered.

I do not agree with the Texas v. White ruling regarding secession. I believe that a people have the right to choose their own destiny and self-governance. Whereas secession may not be the best course for Texas at this time, it is still a course worth conversation and continued debate. Chief Justice Salmon P. Chase himself left the two doors written into the holding — revolution, or the consent of the States — which is worth noticing: even the opinion that calls the Union indissoluble concedes it rests on the states' continuing consent or upon force. The term “indestructible” is not found in the Constitution, it was interpreted through a post-war opinion that preceded the ruling. And that is exactly the argument the case still invites. Therefore, the moment we decide to withdraw our consent, we should be allowed to leave peacefully.

Thank you for listening to Joshua Unfiltered. And this is a value-for-value show. That means if you enjoyed what you heard, if you learned something new, if you received some form of value from listening, I kindly ask that you please share this show with someone you know. In the morning, and thank you for your courage.


Sources

The fork — Social Gospel and Gospel of Wealth

Bellamy and the Pledge

The other fork and the fracture

The landing

Coursework and study

Scripture